ilker/maas-proxmox
1
0
Fork 0
Code Issues Pull Requests Actions Packages Projects Releases 2 Wiki Activity

Separate what was actually verified from what was only written

Browse Source 
The previous "Verified status" section listed the test environment and a
one-line result, which let readers assume far more coverage than the testing
justified. Options that had never run once were presented alongside ones that
were exercised repeatedly.

Every configuration option in the reference tables that was not exercised is now
marked "Untested" inline — 25 of them, including every PVE_NET_* value other than
the tested defaults, PVE_CLUSTER_LINK0/LINK1, fingerprint discovery, the join
retry path, and every PVE_THINPOOL_* value beyond auto with the defaults.

"Verified status" is now two lists. The first gives, per area, the observation
that supports the claim rather than the claim alone: which command was run, what
it printed, which file was found where. The second is everything that was never
exercised, with no implication that it is broken.

Three claims elsewhere were overstated and are corrected:

  * the ~700 MB saving from a local APT cache is an estimate from package sizes;
    that path has never been run
  * MAAS 3.2+ is the documented minimum, but only 3.7.2 with snap packaging was
    tested; the deb packaging's preseed path is untested
  * the build timings are measured, but the contribution of each individual
    optimisation is not

Both cases in "Moving to a new Proxmox release" are also marked: the minor-version
path is verified only as a mechanism (no package versions are pinned), never as an
actual version step, and the claim about upstream breaking on an unknown Debian
release is read from upstream's source rather than observed.

Verified while writing this: the iSCSI initiator names really do differ between
the two nodes, PVE_CLUSTER_WIPE_SECRETS really does scrub both password fields
after a join, and "make preseed" and "make install-preseed" work as targets on the
MAAS region controller rather than only as the commands they wrap.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
ilkermanap
2026-09-04 22:03:19 +02:00
parent 40b5d50ec9
commit 77bf86a1b8
2 changed files with 132 additions and 48 deletions
Download Patch File Download Diff File Expand all files Collapse all files

160
README.md
View File

@@ -156,7 +156,8 @@ fails is retried on the next boot rather than leaving the node half-configured.
**Deployment side:** **Deployment side:**
- MAAS 3.2 or newer (custom image support); tested on 3.7.2 - MAAS 3.2 or newer is the documented minimum for custom images. **Only 3.7.2 was
tested**, with the snap packaging; the deb packaging's preseed path is untested.
- curtin 21.0 or newer - curtin 21.0 or newer
- The curtin preseed from this repository installed on the MAAS region controller - The curtin preseed from this repository installed on the MAAS region controller
@@ -219,7 +220,7 @@ All of these are `make` variables — `sudo make image DISK_SIZE=24G`, and so on
| `PVE_VERSION` | `9` | Proxmox VE major version; used in the image name | | `PVE_VERSION` | `9` | Proxmox VE major version; used in the image name |
| `DEBIAN_SERIES` | `trixie` | Debian codename that Proxmox release is built on | | `DEBIAN_SERIES` | `trixie` | Debian codename that Proxmox release is built on |
| `DEBIAN_VERSION` | `13` | Debian major version number | | `DEBIAN_VERSION` | `13` | Debian major version number |
| `PVE_REPO` | `pve-no-subscription` | `pve-no-subscription`, `pve-enterprise` or `pve-test` | | `PVE_REPO` | `pve-no-subscription` | `pve-no-subscription`, `pve-enterprise` or `pve-test`. *Only `pve-no-subscription` was tested.* |
| `PVE_REPO_URI` | `http://download.proxmox.com/debian/pve` | APT repository URI | | `PVE_REPO_URI` | `http://download.proxmox.com/debian/pve` | APT repository URI |
| `PVE_KEYRING_URL` | derived from `DEBIAN_SERIES` | Proxmox archive keyring | | `PVE_KEYRING_URL` | derived from `DEBIAN_SERIES` | Proxmox archive keyring |
| `PVE_EXTRA_PACKAGES` | `ifupdown2 open-iscsi chrony …` | Extra packages to bake in | | `PVE_EXTRA_PACKAGES` | `ifupdown2 open-iscsi chrony …` | Extra packages to bake in |
@@ -232,8 +233,8 @@ All of these are `make` variables — `sudo make image DISK_SIZE=24G`, and so on
| Variable | Default | Meaning | | Variable | Default | Meaning |
|---|---|---| |---|---|---|
| `IMAGE_NAME` | `proxmox-ve-9` | MAAS name (`custom/<name>`) and preseed filename | | `IMAGE_NAME` | `proxmox-ve-9` | MAAS name (`custom/<name>`) and preseed filename |
| `ARCH` / `SUBARCH` | `amd64` / `generic` | Target architecture | | `ARCH` / `SUBARCH` | `amd64` / `generic` | Target architecture. *Only amd64 was tested.* |
| `BOOT` | `uefi` | Boot mode baked into the image | | `BOOT` | `uefi` | Boot mode baked into the image. *Only UEFI was tested.* |
| `DISK_SIZE` | `16G` | Build VM disk. Upstream's 4G cannot fit Debian + Proxmox | | `DISK_SIZE` | `16G` | Build VM disk. Upstream's 4G cannot fit Debian + Proxmox |
| `BUILD_CPUS` / `BUILD_MEM` | `4` / `4096` | Build VM resources | | `BUILD_CPUS` / `BUILD_MEM` | `4` / `4096` | Build VM resources |
| `TIMEOUT` | `3h` | Packer build timeout | | `TIMEOUT` | `3h` | Packer build timeout |
@@ -243,9 +244,9 @@ All of these are `make` variables — `sudo make image DISK_SIZE=24G`, and so on
| Variable | Default | Meaning | | Variable | Default | Meaning |
|---|---|---| |---|---|---|
| `DEBIAN_IMAGE_CHANNEL` | `stable` | `stable` uses a fixed URL so Packer's cache works; `daily` is upstream's default and changes every day | | `DEBIAN_IMAGE_CHANNEL` | `stable` | `stable` uses a fixed URL so Packer's cache works; `daily` is upstream's default and changes every day. *Only `stable` was tested.* |
| `GZIP_LEVEL` | `6` | Tarball compression. Upstream uses 9 | | `GZIP_LEVEL` | `6` | Tarball compression. Upstream uses 9 |
| `APT_PROXY` | *(empty)* | Local APT cache, e.g. `http://10.0.2.2:3142` — see `make deps-cache` | | `APT_PROXY` | *(empty)* | Local APT cache, e.g. `http://10.0.2.2:3142` — see `make deps-cache`. *Untested.* |
### MAAS ### MAAS
@@ -324,27 +325,27 @@ write_files:
| Option | Default | Meaning | | Option | Default | Meaning |
|---|---|---| |---|---|---|
| `PVE_ENABLED` | `true` | Set to `false` to disable all first-boot automation | | `PVE_ENABLED` | `true` | Set to `false` to disable all first-boot automation. *Untested.* |
| `PVE_FQDN` | *(empty)* | Override the detected FQDN | | `PVE_FQDN` | *(empty)* | Override the detected FQDN. *Untested — detection was used.* |
### Credentials ### Credentials
| Option | Default | Meaning | | Option | Default | Meaning |
|---|---|---| |---|---|---|
| `PVE_ROOT_PASSWORD_HASH` | *(empty)* | `root@pam` password hash — generate with `openssl passwd -6` | | `PVE_ROOT_PASSWORD_HASH` | *(empty)* | `root@pam` password hash — generate with `openssl passwd -6` |
| `PVE_ROOT_PASSWORD` | *(empty)* | Plaintext alternative; prefer the hash | | `PVE_ROOT_PASSWORD` | *(empty)* | Plaintext alternative; prefer the hash. *Untested — only the hash was exercised.* |
### Networking ### Networking
| Option | Default | Meaning | | Option | Default | Meaning |
|---|---|---| |---|---|---|
| `PVE_NET_MANAGE` | `true` | Set to `false` to configure `/etc/network/interfaces` yourself | | `PVE_NET_MANAGE` | `true` | Set to `false` to configure `/etc/network/interfaces` yourself. *`false` untested.* |
| `PVE_NET_BRIDGE` | `vmbr0` | Bridge name | | `PVE_NET_BRIDGE` | `vmbr0` | Bridge name. *Only the default was tested.* |
| `PVE_NET_UPLINK` | *(auto)* | Bridge port; defaults to the interface holding the default route | | `PVE_NET_UPLINK` | *(auto)* | Bridge port; defaults to the interface holding the default route. *Only auto-detection was tested.* |
| `PVE_NET_MODE` | `auto` | `auto`, `static` or `dhcp` | | `PVE_NET_MODE` | `auto` | `auto`, `static` or `dhcp`. *Only `auto` resolving to static was tested; the DHCP path is untested.* |
| `PVE_NET_APPLY` | `reboot` | `reboot`, `reload` (`ifreload -a`) or `none` | | `PVE_NET_APPLY` | `reboot` | `reboot`, `reload` (`ifreload -a`) or `none`. *Only `reboot` was tested.* |
| `PVE_NET_VLAN_AWARE` | `false` | Make the bridge VLAN-aware (`bridge-vids 2-4094`) | | `PVE_NET_VLAN_AWARE` | `false` | Make the bridge VLAN-aware (`bridge-vids 2-4094`). *Untested.* |
| `PVE_NET_EXTRA` | *(empty)* | Raw text appended to `/etc/network/interfaces` | | `PVE_NET_EXTRA` | *(empty)* | Raw text appended to `/etc/network/interfaces`. *Untested.* |
### Cluster ### Cluster
@@ -354,25 +355,25 @@ write_files:
| `PVE_CLUSTER_NAME` | *(empty)* | Cluster name, for `create` | | `PVE_CLUSTER_NAME` | *(empty)* | Cluster name, for `create` |
| `PVE_CLUSTER_PEER` | *(empty)* | Address of an existing member, for `join` | | `PVE_CLUSTER_PEER` | *(empty)* | Address of an existing member, for `join` |
| `PVE_CLUSTER_PEER_PASSWORD` | *(empty)* | That node's `root@pam` password | | `PVE_CLUSTER_PEER_PASSWORD` | *(empty)* | That node's `root@pam` password |
| `PVE_CLUSTER_PEER_PASSWORD_FILE` | *(empty)* | Read the password from a file instead | | `PVE_CLUSTER_PEER_PASSWORD_FILE` | *(empty)* | Read the password from a file instead. *Untested.* |
| `PVE_CLUSTER_FINGERPRINT` | *(empty)* | The peer's certificate SHA-256 fingerprint | | `PVE_CLUSTER_FINGERPRINT` | *(empty)* | The peer's certificate SHA-256 fingerprint |
| `PVE_CLUSTER_FINGERPRINT_DISCOVER` | `true` | Read the fingerprint from the peer if not supplied (trust on first use) | | `PVE_CLUSTER_FINGERPRINT_DISCOVER` | `true` | Read the fingerprint from the peer if not supplied (trust on first use). *Untested — the fingerprint was always supplied.* |
| `PVE_CLUSTER_LINK0` / `LINK1` | *(empty)* | This node's corosync link addresses | | `PVE_CLUSTER_LINK0` / `LINK1` | *(empty)* | This node's corosync link addresses. *Untested.* |
| `PVE_CLUSTER_NODEID` / `VOTES` | *(empty)* | Passed through to Proxmox | | `PVE_CLUSTER_NODEID` / `VOTES` | *(empty)* | Passed through to Proxmox. *Untested.* |
| `PVE_CLUSTER_WAIT` | `900` | Seconds to wait for the peer's API to answer | | `PVE_CLUSTER_WAIT` | `900` | Seconds to wait for the peer's API to answer |
| `PVE_CLUSTER_RETRIES` | `5` | Join attempts, 30 s apart | | `PVE_CLUSTER_RETRIES` | `5` | Join attempts, 30 s apart. *The retry path is untested — the first attempt succeeded.* |
| `PVE_CLUSTER_WIPE_SECRETS` | `true` | Scrub passwords from `conf.d` after joining | | `PVE_CLUSTER_WIPE_SECRETS` | `true` | Scrub passwords from `conf.d` after joining |
### Storage ### Storage
| Option | Default | Meaning | | Option | Default | Meaning |
|---|---|---| |---|---|---|
| `PVE_THINPOOL` | `auto` | `auto` (the VG with the most free space), `off`, or a VG name | | `PVE_THINPOOL` | `auto` | `auto` (the VG with the most free space), `off`, or a VG name. *Only `auto` was tested.* |
| `PVE_THINPOOL_NAME` | `data` | Thin pool logical volume name | | `PVE_THINPOOL_NAME` | `data` | Thin pool logical volume name. *Only the default was tested.* |
| `PVE_THINPOOL_STORAGE` | `local-lvm` | Proxmox storage id | | `PVE_THINPOOL_STORAGE` | `local-lvm` | Proxmox storage id. *Only the default was tested.* |
| `PVE_THINPOOL_MIN_GB` | `16` | Skip the stage below this much free space | | `PVE_THINPOOL_MIN_GB` | `16` | Skip the stage below this much free space |
| `PVE_THINPOOL_DISK` | *(empty)* | Build a new VG from this whole disk instead | | `PVE_THINPOOL_DISK` | *(empty)* | Build a new VG from this whole disk instead. *Untested.* |
| `PVE_THINPOOL_VG` | `pve` | VG name used with `PVE_THINPOOL_DISK` | | `PVE_THINPOOL_VG` | `pve` | VG name used with `PVE_THINPOOL_DISK`. *Untested.* |
Worked examples: [`maas/examples/`](maas/examples/). Worked examples: [`maas/examples/`](maas/examples/).
@@ -632,7 +633,11 @@ next to the metadata of the image you have (`/etc/pve-maas/image-info`).
### Within the same Debian base (9.2 → 9.3 → …) ### Within the same Debian base (9.2 → 9.3 → …)
Nothing to change. No package versions are pinned; every build takes the current Nothing to change. No package versions are pinned; every build takes the current
`proxmox-ve`: `proxmox-ve`.
*Partly verified:* the mechanism is — five builds were made and each installed
whatever the repository offered at the time. An actual minor-version step (a rebuild
that picks up a newer Proxmox than the previous image) has not happened yet.*
```bash ```bash
sudo make image && make verify && make upload sudo make image && make verify && make upload
@@ -652,8 +657,11 @@ debian/scripts/setup-boot.sh: if [ ${DEBIAN_VERSION} == '13' ]
``` ```
An unknown version falls through to the `else` branch, which installs a cloud-init An unknown version falls through to the `else` branch, which installs a cloud-init
package from 2020 — the image breaks silently. A major jump therefore waits on upstream package from 2020 — the image breaks silently.
support. In order:
*This is read from the upstream source, not observed: no build against an unsupported
Debian version was attempted.* A major jump therefore waits on upstream support.
In order:
1. Does `canonical/packer-maas` handle the new Debian? (look at the `DEBIAN_VERSION` 1. Does `canonical/packer-maas` handle the new Debian? (look at the `DEBIAN_VERSION`
conditions in `debian/scripts/`) conditions in `debian/scripts/`)
@@ -682,8 +690,11 @@ Makefile.
## Build performance ## Build performance
A build takes roughly 11 minutes on a 4-vCPU builder, most of it installing packages A build takes about 11 minutes on a 4-vCPU builder, most of it installing packages
inside the build VM. These optimisations are on by default: inside the build VM. Measured on the host described under
[Verified status](#verified-status): 15 min 55 s before these optimisations,
10 min 36 s after. The individual contributions were not measured separately.
All of them are on by default:
- **`eatmydata`** — drops dpkg's per-package `fsync` calls. Safe here: the build VM's - **`eatmydata`** — drops dpkg's per-package `fsync` calls. Safe here: the build VM's
disk is thrown away. disk is thrown away.
@@ -696,7 +707,9 @@ inside the build VM. These optimisations are on by default:
- **`GZIP_LEVEL=6`** — upstream uses `--best` (9). With `pigz` this is noticeably faster - **`GZIP_LEVEL=6`** — upstream uses `--best` (9). With `pigz` this is noticeably faster
for a few percent more size. for a few percent more size.
For repeated builds, a local APT cache removes about 700 MB of downloads: For repeated builds, a local APT cache should remove roughly 700 MB of downloads.
*This path is untested and the figure is an estimate from package sizes, not a
measurement:*
```bash ```bash
sudo make deps-cache # installs apt-cacher-ng sudo make deps-cache # installs apt-cacher-ng
@@ -794,20 +807,87 @@ mode", with GRUB reporting `invalid magic number`.
## Verified status ## Verified status
This repository was tested end to end against live hardware-backed infrastructure: Be sceptical of anything not listed under **Verified**. Individual options are also
marked *Untested* in the tables above where that applies.
### Test environment
| | | | | |
|---|---| |---|---|
| Build host | Ubuntu 24.04.1, x86_64, 8 vCPU / 31 GB, nested KVM |
| MAAS | 3.7.2 (snap), region + rack on Ubuntu 24.04 |
| Nodes | 2 × (2 vCPU, 6 GB RAM, 32 GiB disk), UEFI, Secure Boot off, virtio |
| Network | Single flat isolated subnet; MAAS acting as gateway and DHCP |
| Image | proxmox-ve 9.2.0 / pve-manager 9.2.11 / kernel 7.0.14-15-pve | | Image | proxmox-ve 9.2.0 / pve-manager 9.2.11 / kernel 7.0.14-15-pve |
| MAAS | 3.7.2 (snap) on Ubuntu 24.04, region + rack | | Storage layout | MAAS `lvm`, 12 GiB root LV, ~19 GiB left free in the VG |
| Deployment | `custom/proxmox-ve-9`, amd64/generic, LVM layout with a 12 GiB root |
| Result | Two-node cluster, `Quorate: Yes`, `local-lvm` thin pool on both nodes |
| Automation | Bridge conversion, root password, node identity, cluster create and join — all without logging in |
Not yet exercised: `PVE_CLUSTER_LINK0` (a separate corosync network), the ### Verified
`pve-enterprise` repository, arm64, and `deploy-cluster.sh` beyond `--dry-run`.
--- Each of these was observed working on the running system, not merely assumed:
| Area | Evidence |
|---|---|
| Build | Completes on a KVM-capable Ubuntu 24.04 host; 10 min 36 s with the speed options on, 15 min 55 s without |
| Image contents | `make verify` — 22 checks, all passing |
| Preseed install | `make preseed` and `make install-preseed` run on the MAAS region controller |
| Upload | Image accepted by MAAS as `custom/proxmox-ve-9`, one complete resource set, SHA-256 matching the built file |
| Deployment | `custom/proxmox-ve-9`, amd64/generic, UEFI, LVM layout — reaches `Deployed` |
| `curtin-hooks` — kernel | Deployment no longer fails in "Configuring OS"; no kernel installed over APT |
| `curtin-hooks` — interface naming | `/etc/systemd/network/10-maas-enp6s18.link` written; the interface comes up as `enp6s18` and cloud-init attempts no rename |
| Node identity reset | Both nodes report their MAAS hostname; `/etc/pve/nodes/` holds `maas-node8` and `maas-node9`, not the build hostname |
| `hosts` stage | `/etc/hosts` maps the management IP to the FQDN; the Proxmox banner shows the correct address |
| `identity` stage | iSCSI initiator names regenerated and **different on each node** (`…:01:bfeec443aec7` vs `…:01:4b22246737a`) |
| `rootpw` stage | `PVE_ROOT_PASSWORD_HASH` lands in `/etc/shadow`; the web UI answers on 8006 |
| `network` stage | `vmbr0` up with the management address, `bridge-ports` set to the real interface, node reachable afterwards |
| `cluster` stage — create | `pvecm status`: cluster formed, `Quorate: Yes` |
| `cluster` stage — join | Second node joined on the first attempt in 36 s; both nodes independently report `Nodes: 2`, `Quorate: Yes` |
| `PVE_CLUSTER_WIPE_SECRETS` | Both password fields in `conf.d` scrubbed after joining |
| `storage` stage | `data` thin pool created from free VG space, registered as `local-lvm`, active on both nodes |
| Cluster-wide storage safety | The joining node detected the existing `local-lvm` and added itself to its node list instead of overwriting it |
| Stage resumption | The network stage reboots the node; remaining stages continue on the next boot and completed stages are skipped |
| `deploy-cluster.sh` | `--help` and `--dry-run` against the live MAAS; user-data rendered correctly for a three-node cluster |
| `make check-upstream` | Repository side — reports current `proxmox-ve` / `pve-manager` / `proxmox-default-kernel` versions |
### Not verified
Not known to be broken — simply never exercised. Treat as untested code.
**Options** — see the *Untested* markers in the tables above. In short: every
`PVE_NET_*` value other than the tested defaults, `PVE_CLUSTER_LINK0`/`LINK1`,
fingerprint discovery (TOFU), `PVE_CLUSTER_PEER_PASSWORD_FILE`, the join retry path,
plaintext `PVE_ROOT_PASSWORD`, `PVE_ENABLED=false`, `PVE_FQDN`, and every
`PVE_THINPOOL_*` value other than `auto` with the defaults.
**Build variants**
- `pve-enterprise` and `pve-test` repositories
- arm64
- BIOS boot (`BOOT=bios`)
- `DEBIAN_IMAGE_CHANNEL=daily`
- `APT_PROXY` and `make deps-cache`. The ~700 MB figure quoted under
[Build performance](#build-performance) is an estimate from download sizes, not a
measurement.
- A non-default `IMAGE_NAME`
**Make targets** — `make upload` (the image was uploaded with the equivalent `maas`
command, not through the target), `make deps-cache`, `make clean`, `make distclean`, and
the image side of `make check-upstream`.
**Features added after the last build** — `/etc/pve-maas/image-info` and therefore the
image side of `make check-upstream`. The code is written and syntax-checked; no built
image contains the file yet.
**`deploy-cluster.sh` beyond `--dry-run`.** The underlying mechanism (create, read
fingerprint, join) is verified, but the script's own deploy path has never run.
**Environments** — MAAS releases other than 3.7.2, a deb-packaged MAAS (only the snap
preseed path was used), MAAS storage layouts other than `lvm`, bonded or VLAN-tagged
networking, IPv6 (the network stage writes an `inet6` stanza when a global address
exists; that branch never ran), and real bare metal — the nodes tested were virtual
machines.
**Scale** — two nodes. Concurrent joins by several nodes at once, and clusters larger
than two, are untested.
## Licensing ## Licensing

20
README.tr.md
View File

@@ -46,15 +46,19 @@ imaji (`dd.gz`) ise MAAS'in disk duzenini tamamen devre disi birakir.
## Dogrulanmis durum ## Dogrulanmis durum
Bu depo canli bir ortamda ucdan uca test edildi: **Kanonik ve ayrintili liste [README.md](README.md#verified-status) icindedir** -
neyin test edildigi ve neyin edilmedigi orada secenek secenek isaretlidir.
| | | Ozet: iki dugumlu bir kume, MAAS 3.7.2 uzerinde, elle mudahale olmadan kuruldu
|---|---| (proxmox-ve 9.2.0 / pve-manager 9.2.11 / kernel 7.0.14-15-pve). vmbr0 donusumu,
| Imaj | proxmox-ve 9.2.0 / pve-manager 9.2.11 / kernel 7.0.14-15-pve | root parolasi, dugum kimligi, local-lvm thin havuzu, kume olusturma ve katilma
| MAAS | 3.7.2 (snap), Ubuntu 24.04 region+rack | calisir durumda goruldu.
| Deploy | `custom/proxmox-ve-9`, amd64/generic, LVM duzeni (kok 12GiB) |
| Sonuc | 2 dugumlu kume, `Quorate: Yes`, her iki dugumde `local-lvm` thin havuzu | Test EDILMEYENLER de az degil: `PVE_CLUSTER_LINK0` (ayri corosync agi), parmak izi
| Otomasyon | vmbr0 donusumu, root parolasi, dugum adi, kume olusturma + katilma - hepsi elle mudahalesiz | otomatik kesfi, `PVE_NET_APPLY=reload`, bond/VLAN topolojileri, IPv6, arm64, BIOS
onyukleme, `pve-enterprise` deposu, `deploy-cluster.sh`'in gercek deploy yolu ve
gercek bare-metal donanim (test dugumleri sanal makineydi). Tam liste Ingilizce
dokumanda.
## Gereksinimler ## Gereksinimler